The Scoop

In the News

July 21, 2009

Obama Admits He’s ‘Not Familiar’ With House Bill

With the public’s trust in his handling of health care tanking (50%-44% of Americans disapprove), the White House has launched a new phase of its strategy designed to pass Obamacare: all Obama, all the time. As part of that effort, Obama hosted a conference call with leftist bloggers urging them to pressure Congress to pass his health plan as soon as possible.

During the call, a blogger from Maine said he kept running into an Investors Business Daily article that claimed Section 102 of the House health legislation would outlaw private insurance. He asked: “Is this true? Will people be able to keep their insurance and will insurers be able to write new policies even though H.R. 3200 is passed?” President Obama replied: “You know, I have to say that I am not familiar with the provision you are talking about.” (quote begins at 17:10)

This is a truly disturbing admission by the President, especially considering that later in the call, Obama promises yet again: “If you have health insurance, and you like it, and you have a doctor that you like, then you can keep it. Period.” How can Obama keep making this promise if he is not familiar with the health legislation that is being written in Congress? Details matter.

We are familiar with the passage IBD cites, and as we wrote last week, the House bill does not outright outlaw private individual health insurance, but it does effectively regulate it out of existence. The House bill does allow private insurance to be sold, but only “Exchange-participating health benefits plans.” In order to qualify as an “Exchange-participating health benefits plan,” all health insurance plans must conform to a slew of new regulations, including community rating and guaranteed issue. These will all send the cost of private individual health insurance skyrocketing. Furthermore, all these new regulations would not apply just to individual insurance plans, but to all insurance plans. So the House bill will also drive up the cost of your existing employer coverage as well. Until, of course, it becomes so expensive that your company makes the perfectly economical decision to dump you into the government plan.

President Obama may not care to study how many people will lose their current health insurance if his plan becomes law, but like most Americans, we do. That is why we partnered with the Lewin Group to study how many Americans would be forced into the government “option” under the House health plan. Here is what we found:

– Approximately 103 million people would be covered under the new public plan and, as a consequence, about 83.4 million people would lose their private insurance. This would represent a 48.4 percent reduction in the number of people with private coverage.

– About 88.1 million workers would see their current private, employer-sponsored health plan go away and would be shifted to the public plan.

– Yearly premiums for the typical American with private coverage could go up by as much as $460 per privately-insured person, as a result of increased cost-shifting stemming from a public plan modeled on Medicare.

It is truly frightening that the President of the United States is pressuring Congress in an all-out media blitz to pass legislation that he flatly admits he has not read and is not familiar with. President Obama owes it to the American people to stop making promises about what his health plan will or will not do until he has read it, and can properly defend it in public, to his own supporters.

  • Bookmark and Share
Comments Author: Conn Carroll
  • erinkansas
    I was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis THIS YEAR. My injections cost over $2000 MONTHLY. Now that I have a PRE-EXISTING CONDITION, - will you, the PROTESTERS, PAY for the medicine I will NEED for the REST OF MY LIFE if I want to further my career at a different company?!!
    Private insurance penalizes those with chronic health conditions!!! I pay taxes which helps feed all these illegitimate kids. Why should I not be able to get health insurance?!? If YOU will not help me pay for my lifelong medical condition, then you should keep your insurance as Obama has said SEVERAL TIMES, and I should be able to get help through the reform Obama is pushing.
    YOU PROTESTERS are basically saying that anyone with a chronic condition has to stay at the job they currently are with. I shouldn't be punished into staying at my current job just because IF I LEAVE IT I WONT BE ABLE TO GET HEALTH INSURANCE BECAUSE NOW I HAVE A PRE-EXISTING CONDTION.
    YOU PROTESTERS ARE SELFISH!!!
  • FAHayek89
    Sara,
    The issue is not that Obama didn't know an obsecure section number. The issue is that he was unfamiliar with the content of a section that contridicts a central claim that he has made about the plan. The issue is that he does not know the most important substantative laws in the bill he is pushing so hard to support, and in either not knowing or choosing to ignore the substance of the bill, he is lying to the public about the future availability of private insurance.
  • Sara
    What rubbish - making a case out of the fact that Obama didn't know one section number of the House version of the bill. Not being familiar with a section number is not "flatly admitting" that he doesn't know what the bill is about - pretending that it is simply discredits the entire piece. This is my first visit to this blog, and I can tell you it will be my last - I'm looking for a source of information with integrity, and I'm not finding it here.
  • matt jones
    right. unfortunatly, or rather fortunatly, this article is so transparent as a bit of quote mining idiocy. what the President said was that he was not familiar with a way in which that particular legislation would have the effect that the callere was afraid of. if this was true then it would be devastating to opposition's accusations that the President is attempting to decieve the public: how can the President be part of such a major conspiracy if he openly 'admits' to such flaws. perhaps someone should chechk the logic on these articles, in which they are severely lacking.
  • frustratedwpoliticians
    Congressman Heller of Nevada proposed an amendment that would help prevent illegals from signing up for the government plan, but the ways & means committee, Chaired by Good Ole Charlie Wrangle, shot it down. Please note, they also shot down an amendment that would require members of house & senate to enroll in the government plan. So I ask, if it is not good enough for them, what makes them think it is good enough for the American public?

    http://republicans.waysandmeans.house.gov/tally...
  • robertdavis
    I received an email that said there is a provision in the Obama bill to provide free health care for all illegal aliens in the US. Is this true? If so that should defeat any Congressman who voted for that proviso.
  • faith123name
    Yes I heard the same thing. They are suppose to get automatic amnesty and recieve all government benefits with the exchange for their votes in 2012. If this is passed he want need us at the next election.Most of us will die out anyway.Population control.
blog comments powered by Disqus